How Theft Charges Are Classified: Misdemeanor vs. Felony Theft

When it comes to theft, the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony can significantly impact your future. If you or someone you know is facing theft charges, you should contact an experienced attorney who can help you understand your rights and legal options.
Brian J Lockwood LLC is experienced in handling criminal defense cases in Mobile, Alabama, and the surrounding areas. Theft laws in Alabama can be complicated, but Attorney Lockwood will strive to help you understand your situation and identify the best possible defense.
Theft offenses involve taking someone else’s property without their permission and with the intent to permanently deprive them of it. However, not all theft charges are dealt with in the same way. Depending on the value of the property and other details, theft may be classified as a misdemeanor or a felony, and each carries significantly different legal consequences.
Several factors are used to determine whether a theft case is charged as a misdemeanor or a felony. These classifications are based on state laws as well as the circumstances of the case.
Value of the stolen property: One of the most significant factors is the value or worth of the stolen property. If the item is relatively inexpensive, the charge is more likely to remain a misdemeanor. However, high-value goods quickly push charges into felony territory.
Victim type and circumstances: Another factor that may escalate a case involves the victim. Theft from retailers, individuals, or businesses might be handled differently under state statutes. For example, theft from vulnerable groups, such as the elderly or government entities, could attract harsher penalties.
Criminal history: Your criminal record also matters. A history of prior offenses, even unrelated ones, can lead to heightened charges or sentencing enhancements that add to your penalties.
Method of theft: Certain kinds of theft, like burglary or robbery, elevate the severity of charges, often into felony status, regardless of the value of the property.
Each of these details shapes the case and determines the penalties involved. However, crimes involving fraud, identity theft, or deception are typically treated more seriously than simple or misdemeanor theft charges.
While it's essential to understand the factors that are evaluated in theft cases, it's also important to examine how misdemeanor and felony theft charges differ.
Smaller-scale theft is usually classified as a misdemeanor. For example, petty theft, which typically involves stealing low-value items (like shoplifting inexpensive goods), is a common misdemeanor offense. Misdemeanors generally have lighter penalties than felonies, but that doesn’t mean they can be dismissed lightly.
The potential consequences for misdemeanor theft could include jail time (up to one year), monetary fines, or probation. While misdemeanors may seem minor compared to felonies, they can still leave a lasting mark on your record.
Felony theft charges, on the other hand, are labeled for more severe circumstances, such as stolen items valued above a state's defined felony threshold or instances involving high aggravation like burglary or violent robbery.
These charges have harsh penalties, including prison sentences of over one year, larger fines, and potential restitution to the victim. Being convicted of a felony may also harm your ability to find employment, rent property, or vote.
Like other states, Alabama classifies theft into different degrees. These laws specify which thefts are considered felonies and which are misdemeanors based primarily on property value and other criteria. Alabama typically treats theft charges under the Code of Alabama § 13A-8-1 through § 13A-8-24:
First degree (Class B Felony): Theft of property valued at $2,500 or more, theft of a motor vehicle, or theft involving the use of force. Punishment could include 2-20 years in prison.
Second degree (Class C Felony): Theft of property valued between $1,500 and $2,500, theft involving firearms, or theft against individuals unable to consent, such as the elderly. Punishment typically includes 1-10 years in prison.
Third degree (Class D Felony): Theft of property between $500 and $1,500. This charge carries a possible prison term of 1-5 years.
Fourth degree (Class A Misdemeanor): Theft of property below $500. Misdemeanors may lead to up to one year in jail or limited fines.
These categories can vary based on aggravating circumstances or the involvement of prior convictions. The details matter because they determine what you’re up against, while the consequences can range from community service and probation to years in prison.
Understanding theft classifications is essential to protect your future. The consequences of a conviction go well beyond the immediate legal penalties like jail time or fines. A criminal record can impact your ability to find employment, secure loans, or even rent an apartment.
For instance, a misdemeanor may only create short-term difficulties, while a felony conviction could cause long-term damage to your personal and professional reputation. Understanding your charges lets you make informed decisions about your defense strategy and evaluate plea deals carefully.
As a dedicated criminal defense attorney, Brian J Lockwood strives to defend those accused of serious theft offenses, whether misdemeanors or felonies. If you've been accused of theft, Brian J Lockwood LLC offers personalized representation in Mobile, Alabama, and the surrounding areas. Reach out today to schedule a consultation.